Even if you don’t have plans to leave anytime soon, it’s not unreasonable to consider what happens to your employee stock options when no longer work for your current employer.
Whether due to a planned retirement after a long career, a new opportunity at another company, or an intentional sabbatical from the workforce, there are plenty of good reasons why you won’t be at your company forever.
There are also less-desirable circumstances under which you might leave. While no one hopes or plans to be let go, fired, or forced to stop working for a negative reason, these things do happen.
Either way, for better or worse, it’s important to know what happens to your employee stock options upon terminating your relationship with your employer.
The answer to what happens can get complicated. Depending on why your employment status changes from employee to former employee and what type(s) of employee stock option(s) you have, the rules surrounding what you can and can’t do with your equity compensation will vary.
The best strategy is to check your plan document for the specific rules regarding your plan. But in the meantime, here is a primer of things to know now.
The Basics of Employee Stock Options When You Terminate Your Employment
Employee stock options are issued with an expiration date. The expiration date is important because it lets you know the last day you can capture the value of employee stock options via an exercise.
The expiration date is usually ten years from the grant date. However, every plan is subject to its own rules; again, you should check your plan document to determine specific details like this.
Regardless of when the date is, if you do not exercise and the expiration date comes and goes, your option will terminate and you will lose the ability to exercise. Subsequently, you forfeit any imbedded value. This happens even if you’re still employed with the company.
Your right to exercise your employee stock options may change, however, as your employment status changes. Generally speaking, if you are terminating your employment from your company, you will need to exercise your employee stock options at the earlier of the expiration date or the new expiration period set in the plan document for a terminated employee.
Change in employment status can be segmented into several categories:
- Termination by choice
- Termination by disability
- Termination by death
Your plan document should help you determine what your post-termination expiration provisions are once you know the circumstances around your departure.
Vesting Stops When You Leave Your Company
Prior to getting into your post-termination exercise periods, you should know that when you leave the company for any reason, unvested shares remain unvested in almost all cases.
Practically speaking, this means that the in-the-money value of unvested employee stock options is forfeited. The negative impact to your net-worth statement of forfeiting potentially valuable unvested options may be material if you are considering termination employment.
Let’s assume that you have the following employee stock options
|Grant||Shares||Vested||Exercise Price||FMV||Total Value||Vested Value|
In this scenario, you have a total employee stock option value of $805,000 if we consider vested and unvested stock options.
Only 25,000 of the 35,000 options are vested here, meaning your current exercisable value is $585,000. That’s considerably lower than the total value of $805,000.
In order to obtain the full value, you have to stay employed with the company until the 10,000 options in Grant 3 vest. Assuming you do work until Grant 3 vests, you will have access to those shares as well. But if you terminate your employment prior to Grant 3 vesting, the value of Grant 3 goes away.
The decision to leave your employer when you know that it means forfeiting unvested options may be critically important in the financial planning process.
If I had a client who wanted to leave because they wanted to retire, for example, we might model out retirement income projections. As part of the projection, we need to know whether to include the $805,000 of total stock option value — or $585,000 of stock option value that could actually be realized and not forfeited before some of the shares vest.
That’s a $220,000 difference, which can make a big impact on how much you can spend in retirement.
If we assume a 3-5% withdrawal rate in retirement, its reasonable to assume that a retirement with only vested shares in this example may be between $6,600 and $11,000 less per year than what this client could spend in retirement per year if all the shares vested.
The timeline until your unvested shares vest is also important. If we assume that Grant 3 is scheduled to vest in the near term, it may make sense to work a little longer, allowing the shares to vest and you to capture the value.
Alternatively, if the shares do not vest for several years, the value of the unvested options is not an important part of your retirement plan, or both, then pulling the trigger to retire and forfeiting the option shares may be a better choice for you.
Exercise Timeline if You Leave to Take Another Job or Retire
If you leave your company voluntarily, either to retire, to take another job, or to take a break from work, you generally have up to 3 months or 90 days from your termination date to exercise your vested options. (As always, check your plan document as this period can be shorter or longer.)
Even if the expiration date of your employee stock options is further out in time than the 90-day exercise window, you must exercise within this new post-termination period.
However, if your original expiration date is after you terminate your employment but prior to the end of the 90-day post termination exercise window, you will need to exercise by that original expiration date to capture the value.
If you have incentive stock options, your post-termination exercise considerations may become even more complicated.
For an incentive stock option to retain its status as such, you must exercise the option within 90 days of termination of your company. This probably won’t be a problem if the 90-day period coincides with the requirement of the plan document.
But if your company gives you one year from termination to exercise your incentive stock options, you will need to exercise them within the 90-day post-termination period even though you have up to one year per the plan document in order to retain their status as incentive stock options.
Both an approaching expiration date and a change of employment status signify a point where you need to make decisions around your options. Choosing not to exercise means that you run the risk of losing the ability to capture in the money stock option value.
What Happens If You Become Disabled (or Worse, Die)?
Generally speaking, the timeline you have to exercise your employee stock options is longer if you become disabled than it is if you terminate for another reason. Often, you will have one year from the date you terminate employment to exercise your employee stock options.
If you have incentive stock options and become disabled, the 3-month post-termination exercise period is extended to 12 months. This allows for additional time to strategize the best way exercise your options and plan for the future.
Like the post-termination period if you become disabled, the post-termination exercise period for employee stock options if you die is longer than if you leave for another reason. Commonly, one year is used. But as always, you want to check your plan document to determine if your period is shorter or longer.
If you have incentive stock options, the rule that requires incentive stock options to be exercised within 3-months of job termination (or in this case, death) to retain status as an ISO is waived, so long as you were employed as of your date of death or within the 3 months preceding death.
Many plans will allow you to name a beneficiary of your employee stock options. This person may be able to act on your stock options upon death. They will have the right to exercise the options, sell the options, and/or received the stock shares themselves.
In lieu of a beneficiary, your personal representative in charge of handling your estate affairs will likely be able to assist in the exercise of the shares.
Before You Leave Your Company, Understand What Might Happen with Your Stock Options
When you leave your company, you likely have a short-term period during which you can exercise your remaining stock options. During this time, it’s a now-or-never proposition.
Exercise and capture the proceeds, or let them expire and lose what you have.
With that said, some advanced planning may be available to you. A first step is to check the document to know what timeframes you are dealing with. Know how long you have to exercise and how different circumstances for leaving might impact that timeline.
Next, plan and strategize for your incentive stock options. You might want to consider exercising within the 90-day period in order to retain the ISO status.
And finally, consider how your available exercise periods “wrap” around one calendar year or two. For example, if your 90-day exercise window is between November 1 of one year and January 31 of the next, you may be able to spread income over 2 years, which is helpful for tax purposes.
A good strategy will know the allowable timeframes and plan accordingly. This planning may include executing an early exercise of some (or all) of your options in an effort to avoid a significant singular tax bill due to a change of jobs.
The content herein is for illustrative purposes only and does not attempt to predict actual results of any particular investment. Diversification does not guarantee a profit or protect against a loss. None of the information in this document should be considered as tax advice. You should consult your tax advisor for information concerning your individual situation. Tax services are not offered through, or supervised by, The Lincoln Investment Companies.